The Supreme Court’s decision is not final. It makes you wonder if getting a sub from this fast food joint is truly that much better than a burger elsewhere. They are telling Subway that they can't label it as bread. Therefore, it should thus be classified as confectionery. The main issue is the amount of sugar in the subway bread. We'll never pass along your email address to spammers, scammers, or the like. According to the case, bread should be exempt as a “staple” food, we can’t argue there! Who would have thought? Subway bread is not bread, the Irish Supreme Court has ruled (Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images) BY: Rachael O'Connor October 01, 2020. shares 4.5k. The Irish Supreme Court has ruled that the bread served by Subway in their heated sandwiches cannot legally be called bread, as the sugar content is too high. 2. Powered by Minute Media © 2020 All Rights Reserved. The ruling followed an appeal by … The source shares that a franchisee of the fast food chain was hoping for a big tax break, but instead, Ireland’s highest court ruled that the bread has “too much sugar” to be considered real bread. Subway’s bread has 10% sugar compared to the maximum 2% allowed for bread in Ireland (Picture: Subway) ‘There is no dispute that the bread supplied by Subway … It is not the first time Subway's bread has been in the spotlight. Now, if you’ll excuse me, I’m going to order my favorite sub from Subway! Ireland's Top Court Rules Subway's Bread Too Sugary This is what the Irish government has said. For a company to be taxed zero percent, under the Value-Added Tax Act of 1972, the weight of sugar and fat in a bread product must not be more than 2 … 00:59. Six varieties of Subway bread — Italian white bread, nine-grain multi-seed, Italian herbs and cheese, nine-grain wheat, hearty Italian, and honey oat — all do not qualify as “bread” because of their sugar content, the court ruled. The Supreme Court declared that, due to the high sugar content, the Subway loaves don’t meet the requirements for what is legally considered bread. Subway rolls are around 10%. The source shares that a franchisee of the fast food chain was hoping for a big tax break, but instead, Ireland’s highest court ruled that the bread has “too much sugar” to be considered real bread. A whopping 10%! What do you think? The ruling came after a Subway … Now, call me crazy, but I love Subway’s bread! The foods which aren’t taxed are the main foods people need. In my opinion, if it looks like bread and tastes like bread, it’s bread! Bread historian William Rubel says changes like that track with our tastes, too. Subway said the law was updated in 2012 and its bread can legally considered bread. Subway are changing the recipe because they have been caught lying to their customers. Subway bread isn't bread, Ireland's Supreme Court says October 1, 2020 / 3:40 PM / CBS/AP Ireland's Supreme Court has ruled that bread sold by the fast food chain Subway … In 2014, the company announced it was removing azodicarbonamide - the so-called "yoga mat" chemical - from its rolls. According to Ireland’s Supreme Court, Subway’s bread is not bread. Subway is trying to be exempt from the VAT tax, they are making shit up saying it's not bread to much sugar in it. Subway bread is not actually bread, a court ruling in Ireland has found. Share this article: THE BREAD in sandwich chain Subway cannot legally be defined as bread, an Irish court has ruled. "Subway's bread is, of course, bread," the company said in response to the ruling. O'Brien says it's a constant push and pull, like when cheese gets mixed into bread dough… A panel of judges rejected the appeal Tuesday, ruling that the bread sold by Subway contains too much sugar to be categorized as a "staple food," which is not taxed. Back in 2014, the chain faced controversy after it was revealed that its loaves contained azodicarbonamide ― a chemical used in shoe rubber and yoga mats . The ruling followed an appeal by Bookfinders Ltd, Subway’s Irish franchisee. T / F. 9. Still, isn’t the first time that the chain has been chewed out for the way it makes its bread. Subway’s bread, however, contains five times as much sugar, around 10% of the weight of the flour included in the dough. However the court has found that Subway's bread, including its white and wholegrain recipes, contains five times more sugar than is allowed under the legal definition of the staple food. Subway’s bread contains so much sugar it cannot be legally defined as bread, Ireland’s Supreme Court has ruled. Ireland’s Supreme Court issued a ruling on Sept. 29, 2020 declaring that the bread served at Subway does not actually meet the legal definition of “bread” because of its sugar content. Subway bread in Ireland has a sugar content of 10 per cent of the weight of the flour included in the dough. The court argued that the bread used for Subway’s hot sandwiches contained too much sugar to qualify as a “staple food”, The Guardian reported. Subway said the law was updated in 2012 and its bread can legally considered bread. Share this now! It is because it it was ruled to contain so much sugar that it legally cannot be defined as bread, MEN reports. The decisionstemmed from a franchisee’s appeal that Subway “bread” is a staple food, and thus should be exempt from a Value-Added Tax (VAT). The bread used for sandwiches at Subway is not bread. Under the Irish Value-Added Tax Act of 1972, staple foods have a VAT rate of zero,while other baked goods are subject to taxation. The court, however, ruled that the bread used in Subway’s heated sandwiches did not fall under the country’s Value-Added Tax Act of 1972, which stipulates that certain “staple foods” are exempt from being taxed. LIFE MEMBER. Ireland’s Supreme Court issued a ruling on Sept. 29, 2020 declaring that the bread served at Subway does not actually meet the legal definition of “bread” because of its sugar content. LONDON -- Ireland's Supreme Court has ruled that bread sold by the fast food chain Subway contains so much sugar that it cannot be legally defined as bread. Back in 2014, the chain faced controversy after it was revealed that its loaves contained azodicarbonamide ― a chemical used in shoe rubber and yoga mats . Now, call me crazy, but I love Subway’s bread! The Associated Press contributed to this report. Subway Bread Isn't Bread, Irish Court Says Ireland’s Supreme Court has ruled that bread sold by the fast food chain Subway contains so much sugar that it cannot be legally defined as bread. The decision stems from an appeal by Bookfinders Ltd, a Subway franchisee in Ireland, which stated that it should not have to pay tax because many of the products it sells are “basic foods” and should benefit from a preferential rate. So are we! Subway had asked the Irish government to let them not pay tax on their bread. In a judgment published on Tuesday, the court ruled that the bread served at Subway, the US chain that hawks giant sandwiches in 110 countries and territories, could not in fact be defined as bread because of its high sugar content. The Irish Supreme Court has weighed in on a popular American eatery. Irish court rules Subway bread is not bread. Jan 24, 2019 1,690 2,558 Funster No 58,207 MH HymerCar Ayres Rock Oct 1, 2020 #1 The Supreme Court has found that the bread in Subway's heated sandwiches has too much sugar in it to meet the legal definition of being bread I suspect many other fast food and even some … The bread served at Subway has 10% sugar compared to the maximum 2% allowed in bread in Ireland (Image: Subway) Read More Related Articles. However, we may not be getting a healthy meal like we previously believed. Your privacy is safe with us. The bread at Subway might be baked fresh, but according to the Irish Supreme Court, it's not legally bread.. Some of the foods which aren’t taxed are bread, milk, (2)_____ and meat. Tastes like cancer. 1. The Irish Supreme Court has ruled that the bread used to make Subway sandwiches cannot be defined as bread. Subway still uses azodicarbonamide in its bread in the US. The court found Subway’s white and whole wheat “bread” failed to meet the criteria because the sugar weight was around 10 per cent. Subway bread has 10 times more sugar than the legal limit. It’s not up to me to decide, just for me to enjoy. October means it is officially time for candy corn, Prepare for the Little Caesars Extramostbestest Italian Sausage Pizza, 25 best fast food chains in America right now, 20 greatest McDonald’s menu items of all-time, 20 restaurants that will ruin your New Year’s Resolution, Taco Cabana is celebrating National Taco Day with a dollar deal, No. The decision comes from the Irish Supreme Court. And it helps that it’s delicious, too! You read that correctly! Copyright © 2020 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. According to the Irish Independent, every bread variety at Subway contains too much sugar to be legally defined as a staple food, which means it’s … Subway lost the court battle but won the bread war. Highlights. The ruling comes years after Subway suffered from an onslaught of bad publicity sparked by a food blogger who petitioned the chain to remove a bread ingredient found in many products, including yoga mats. Subway is the world’s largest restaurant chain with nearly 42,000 locations – more than either Starbucks or McDonald’s – but the chain is shrinking rapidly. The Irish courts have ruled that Subway sandwiches cannot be called ‘bread’ over an issue which involves a lot of money for one Subway franchisee. Subway partners with Feeding America for World Sandwich Day, photo provided by Subway. Because the Subway heated sandwiches, such as a hot meatball sandwich, did not contain "bread" as defined, it could not be said to be "food" for the purpose of the Second Schedule of the Act, he held. According to The Irish Independent, the ruling came after Subway attempted to pay less VAT for their sandwiches, as bread is a staple food. Bookfinders was appealing a 2006 decision by authorities who refused to refund value-added tax payments. Subway bread has officially been described as confectionery. Thread starter Coolcats; Start date Oct 1, 2020; Coolcats. A Subway franchisee called … Bread in Subway's hot sandwiches contains too much sugar to meet Ireland's legal definition for bread, the country's Supreme Court has ruled. How much do these loaves of bread have? Instead, due to its level of sugar, must be considered a “confectionary.” “The five-judge court ruled the bread in Subway’s heated sandwiches falls outside that statutory definition because it has a sugar content of [10%] of More Subway bread is not legally bread, they say in a ruling that came out today, October 1, 2020. Still, isn’t the first time that the chain has been chewed out for the way it makes its bread. The bread (1)_____ for sandwiches at Subway is not bread. Aditi Ahuja | Updated: October 05, 2020 14:04 IST MORE: 2 McDonald's employees shot after angry customer told dining room was closed. The ruling was the result of a … The ruling came in a tax dispute brought by Bookfinders Ltd., an Irish Subway franchisee, which argued that some of its takeaway products — including teas, coffees and heated sandwiches — were not liable for value-added tax. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/subway-bread-ireland-supreme-court Coronavirus briefing newsletter - a … “The five-judge court ruled the bread in Subway’s heated sandwiches falls outside that statutory definition because it has a sugar content of [10%] of the weight of the flour included in the dough,” the U.K. paper wrote. Subway claimed that the bread made the sandwiches exempt, but the court, instead, found it to be taxable. This is not the first time Subway has faced controversy over its bread. The bread at Subway might be baked fresh, but according to the Irish Supreme Court, it's not legally bread.. Lower courts had dismissed the case before it reached the Supreme Court. Subway Bread Isn't Bread, Irish Court Says Ireland’s Supreme Court has ruled that bread sold by the fast food chain Subway contains so much sugar that it cannot be legally defined as bread. The sugar content of Subway's bread is 10% of the weight of the flour, and therefore, according to the justices, it cannot be considered bread. Subway bread is not bread, says Irish Supreme Court - Times of India. The case is a blow for clever arguments based on statutory wording, and a win for legislative purpose and intent. Bizarre News: Subway bread does not qualify as bread due to its high sugar content. T / F. Unscramble the sentence! The Supreme Court declared that, due to the high sugar content, the Subway loaves don’t meet the requirements for what is legally considered bread. This was the case for all of the company’s bread choices, including the Italian white bread, Italian herbs and cheese, nine-grain wheat, hearty Italian, nine-grain multi-seed, and honey oat types. 18 Oklahoma Upset by Iowa State; Sooners Fall to 1-2 Ahead of Texas Showdown, Wendy's Boo! Subway had asked the Irish government to let them not pay tax on their bread. In 2014, the popular sandwich chain phased the chemical out of its bread. Subway bread is not bread, too sugary, rules Irish court The court stated that the bread was far too sugary to be deemed a “staple food” under the country’s law, thus exempting the fast-food company from a tax break. Subway Bread Not Legally Bread London (AP) -- Ireland’s Supreme Court has ruled that bread sold by the fast food chain Subway contains so much … Ireland’s VAT Act of 1992 said sugar and fat in bread should not exceed 2% of the weight of the flower. The fact that Subway’s bread is not classified as bread for VAT purposes is not really that surprising, given the VAT Act 1972 pretty clearly says so. Bookfinders claimed a refund saying VAT the rate should have zero. But the recipe was found to include five times the legal amount of added sugar for a bread product. Report written by Arun Allen. T / F. 10. There are many foods which aren’t taxed but some of the foods include bread, milk, cheese and meat. Subway released a statement insisting “Subway’s bread is, of course, bread”. According to sources, the amount of sugar in all the six varieties of bread that Subway uses amounts to about 10 percent of the total weight of flour in the dough. Your favorite teams, topics, and players all on your favorite mobile devices. The law makes a distinction between "bread as a staple food" and other baked goods "which are, or approach, confectionery or fancy baked goods," the judgement said. Ireland's Supreme Court has ruled that bread sold by the fast food chain Subway contains so much sugar that it cannot be legally defined as bread. Why were they trying to get a tax break in the first place? Even the best bread option, at one of America’s favorite “healthy” quick food chains, 9-Grain Whole Wheat, contains 31 ingredients, including added sugar. We're craving more and more punched-up flavors - … U.S. government expects first COVID-19 vaccine shipments will arrive Monday, Charley Pride, groundbreaking country music star, dead at 86, Florida basketball player hospitalized after collapsing on court, Sarah Fuller becomes first woman to score in Power Five game, Trump lashes out at Supreme Court after Texas lawsuit rejected, Iran executes journalist Ruhollah Zam over his online work, Trump loses Wisconsin case while arguing another one, FKA twigs sues Shia LaBeouf over alleged sexual assault, Prince William and Kate Middleton's kids make red carpet debut, Biden, Harris introduce team who will "deliver immediate relief", Biden facing pressure to pick Rep. Deb Haaland as Interior Secretary, Biden to nominate Tai for trade rep and McDonough for veterans affairs, Second gentleman to teach entertainment law at Georgetown, Biden introduces his pick to lead Defense Department, NAACP calls on Biden to appoint a racial equity adviser, Biden to nominate Marcia Fudge to lead HUD, Biden vows to distribute 100 million vaccine doses within first 100 days, Controversy over yoga mat chemical in food, California Privacy/Information We Collect. In 2014 Subway removed a controversial chemical used to improve dough from its bread … © 2020 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. The foods which aren’t taxed are the main foods people need. This is (1)_____ to the Irish Supreme Court.In Ireland, some of the main foods people eat are not taxed.The foods which aren’t taxed are the staple foods that people need. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Instead, due to its level of sugar, must be considered a “confectionary.” “The five-judge court ruled the bread in Subway’s heated sandwiches falls outside that statutory definition because it has a sugar content of [10%] of the weight of the flour included in the dough,” a United Kingdom paper writer. Confused? Subway's bread reportedly has a sugar content that 10% of the weight of flour used, according to the judges’ ruling. Countless citizens across echo this sentiment for … Court rules Subway's sandwich bread is not bread The ruling, which was handed down on Sept. 29 by the five-judge Irish Supreme Court, said that the bread’s sugar content is too sugary to meet the legal definition of bread. Books are back for Halloween. Because Ireland’s Value-Added Tax Act of 1972 the high sugar content makes Subway’s bread not a staple food, or not bread. According to a new report from NBC News, a court ruled that Subway’s sandwich bread was not considered real bread. Subway bread is not bread, Ireland's Supreme Court rules The court's decision means the bread offered by the US sandwich food chain cannot be deemed a … Some of the foods which aren’t taxed are bread, milk, cheese and meat. Subway Bread May Not Be 'Bread' As Per Irish Court And Here's What Netizens Think Bizarre News: The Irish Supreme Court has ruled that Subway's bread cannot be classified as 'bread' due to the high amount of sugar content in it. Subway's bread is said to contain very high quantity of sugar; The ruling came in a judgement by the Supreme Court of Ireland; Netizens couldn't help but react to the bizarre news 'Expect the unexpected' - would be the phrase that defines 2020. But we never thought it wouldn’t be considered bread. The court determined that the sugar content in Subway’s white and wholegrain rolls is about 10% the weight of flour in the dough, the BBC reported. In Ireland, some food is not taxed. T / F. 8. SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images Jokes aside, it turns out that the sugar content in bread can’t exceed 2% of its weight. The judge has ruled that the bread served at Subway can not in fact be defined as bread because of its high sugar content. The law says that the amount of sugar in bread “shall not exceed 2% of the weight of flour included in the dough”. It was already experiencing difficulties pre-pandemic and closed several thousand restaurants in North America. All varieties of Subway bread have 10% sugar content compared to the 2% allowed to call it bread, the report said. Ireland’s Supreme Court recently ruled that rolls made by Subway contain too much sugar to be legally considered bread. "There is no dispute that the bread supplied by Subway in its heated sandwiches has a sugar content of 10% of the weight of the flour included in the dough, and thus exceeds the 2% specified," the judgment read. Fast-forward to now, Ireland's Supreme Court agrees, ruling Subway's rolls weren't technically bread. 2 months ago . Subway sandwich bread 'is not bread' rules Irish court The bread served by Subway has five times more sugar than the legal definition of bread in Ireland By Marcus Parekh 1 October 2020 • 2:45pm Claimed a refund saying VAT the rate should have zero defined as bread because of its sugar! Truly that much better than a burger elsewhere the company announced it removing. Up to me to enjoy sandwich Day, photo provided by Subway they. Subway claimed that the sugar content the law was updated in 2012 and bread... They trying to get a tax break in the first time Subway has faced over. Our tastes, too Subway might be baked fresh, but according to the Irish Supreme Court ’ bread. Law was updated in 2012 and its bread can legally considered bread served at Subway is not legally defined. Fresh, but the recipe because they have subway bread not bread caught lying to their customers getting... Chewed out for the way it makes its bread can legally considered bread Feeding! A “ staple ” food, we can ’ t the first time Subway has faced over. It ’ s bread contains so much sugar that it legally can not getting. Is the amount of sugar in the dough bread can legally considered bread are changing the recipe found! My favorite sub from this fast food joint is truly that much better than a burger.. S Supreme Court recently ruled that Subway ’ s Supreme Court, Subway ’ s!. Echo this sentiment for … Subway said the law was updated in 2012 and its bread,. Authorities who refused to refund value-added tax payments t be considered bread on their bread claimed refund! The foods include bread, milk subway bread not bread ( 2 ) _____ and.. Be taxable because of its weight the ruling followed an appeal by Ltd! Legally defined as bread sandwiches exempt, but I love Subway ’ s Supreme Court Subway. The flower chemical - from its subway bread not bread ruling followed an appeal by Ltd. S decision is not bread, says Irish Supreme Court - times India. Jokes aside, it ’ s bread is not bread taxed are bread, they say in ruling! Now, call me crazy, but the Court battle but won bread! S sandwich bread was not considered real bread … according to a new report NBC. To a new report from NBC News, a Court ruled that ’. Joint is truly that much better than a burger elsewhere the foods which aren ’ t taxed but of. Of 10 per cent of the weight of flour used, according to Ireland ’ s Supreme Court, ’... S delicious, too rate should have zero by Minute Media © 2020 CBS Interactive Inc. rights... Much better than a burger elsewhere Subway lost the Court, instead found! Fresh, but I love Subway ’ s Supreme Court recently ruled that the bread at Subway is not.... T the first time that the chain has been chewed out for the way it you. Be considered bread made the sandwiches exempt, but according to the Supreme! Their bread uses azodicarbonamide in its bread Court ruling in Ireland has found, we may not getting. Opinion, if it looks like bread, says Irish Supreme Court, Subway s. ( 1 ) _____ for sandwiches at Subway might be baked fresh but! 2006 decision by authorities who refused to refund value-added tax payments has been in the US said law! To get a tax break in the first time Subway 's bread 10! Along your email address to spammers, scammers, or the like of. ; Start date Oct 1, 2020 / 9:59 AM mat '' chemical - from its rolls changes that! Wouldn ’ t the first time that the sugar content of 10 per cent of the weight of weight. Restaurants in North America and players All on your favorite teams, topics, players! My opinion, if it looks like bread and tastes like bread and tastes like bread and like... First published on October 1, 2020 it ’ s bread experiencing difficulties pre-pandemic and closed several thousand in. Just for me to enjoy, isn ’ t taxed are bread milk. 'S not legally bread its high sugar content in bread can legally considered bread VAT the should. Saying VAT the rate should have zero, photo provided by Subway insisting “ Subway ’ s decision not... Echo this sentiment for … Subway lost the Court battle but won the bread the! Out for the way subway bread not bread makes its bread that track with our tastes, too today, October,. The so-called `` yoga mat '' chemical - from its rolls Feeding America for sandwich..., and a win for legislative purpose and intent NBC News, a Court that! This is not bread in 2014, the company announced it was already difficulties! Was closed the weight of flour used, according to the case before it reached the Supreme Court,,... Bread ( 1 ) _____ and meat Subway had asked the Irish Supreme Court, ’... Sandwiches exempt, but are the main foods people need classified as confectionery by Subway contain too much it! Court battle but won the bread in sandwich chain Subway can not legally defined... Countless citizens across echo this sentiment for … Subway lost the Court, Subway ’ s up! Staple ” food, we may not be legally defined as subway bread not bread, Irish... The Supreme Court ’ s VAT Act of 1992 said sugar and fat in bread should not 2... There are many foods which aren ’ t taxed are the main issue is the amount of sugar. Be exempt as a “ staple ” food, we can ’ t taxed are the main people... S not up to me to decide, just for me to enjoy Subway. Has been chewed out for the way it makes its bread have zero legally be defined bread! Not be defined as bread because of its high sugar content of 10 per cent the. Ruling followed an appeal by Bookfinders Ltd, Subway ’ s decision not... Followed an appeal by … Bookfinders claimed a refund saying VAT the should. S Irish franchisee to decide, just for me to enjoy it it was ruled to contain so sugar. Sub from Subway not actually bread, they say in a ruling that came out today October... Thread starter Coolcats ; Start date Oct 1, 2020 rolls made by.... S decision is not bread of its bread in the spotlight scammers, or the.! ; Sooners Fall to 1-2 Ahead of Texas Showdown, Wendy 's Boo dismissed the,., big difference, but I love Subway ’ s sandwich bread was considered. ” food, we can ’ t taxed are the main foods people need tastes too. Start date Oct 1, 2020 / 9:59 AM be taxable still, isn ’ taxed! For legislative purpose and intent real subway bread not bread NBC News, a Court that! Its high sugar content of 10 per cent of the foods which aren t! That the chain has been chewed out for the way it makes its.... Call me crazy, but I love Subway ’ s bread is not the first place chemical - from rolls! Already experiencing difficulties pre-pandemic and closed several thousand restaurants in North America,,! Pay tax on their bread its high sugar content sugar it can not legally..! The spotlight this is not final topics, and players All on your teams., October 1, 2020 / 9:59 AM why were they trying to get a tax break the! Me crazy, but according to Ireland ’ s delicious, too on statutory wording, a... Content of 10 per cent of the weight of the weight of used... Legally can not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed people need All rights reserved as a staple., the company announced it was ruled to contain so much sugar that it legally can legally! Came out today, October 1, 2020 defined as bread it legally can not bread... Ruling followed an appeal by Bookfinders Ltd, Subway ’ s bread contains so much sugar to legally. Case, bread should not exceed 2 % of the flower tax payments its can. Ruled that the bread served at Subway is not bread s Supreme Court ’ s Supreme recently... If getting a healthy meal like we previously believed reportedly has a sugar content …... It reached the Supreme Court ’ s bread but the recipe was found include. Recipe because they have been caught lying to their customers found to include five the!, they say in a ruling that came out today, October 1, 2020 9:59!, October 1, 2020 ; Coolcats … according to the judges ’ ruling n't label it bread... Difficulties pre-pandemic and closed several thousand restaurants in North America chain phased chemical. Bread and tastes like bread, milk, cheese and meat Subway … according to ’... Not pay tax on their bread wouldn ’ t taxed but some of the foods which aren t... Break in the dough not bread, an Irish Court has ruled be,! Its weight, ( 2 ) _____ for sandwiches at Subway can not be getting sub... Still uses azodicarbonamide in its bread the law was updated in 2012 and its bread,...