In this way, populist arguments about climate change resemble those about immigration. During the Red Scare following World War II, McCarthy boasted he had proof that communist spies had infiltrated the federal government. Populism is a political phenomenon. History Reads features the work of prominent authors and historians. But it, too, could have an upside. Trump has shown no signs of abandoning his populist posturing as president. Joseph McCarthy's brand of populism proved much darker than, say, Ronald Reagan's. If the 2010s were the years in which predominantly far-right, populist parties permeated the political mainstream, then the 2020s will be when voters “are going to see the consequences of that,” Daphne Halikiopoulou, an associate professor of comparative politics at the University of Reading, in England, told me. Instead of tapping into populism’s powerful language and rich tradition to inspire and motivate people to be part of a movement that is larger than themselves, he has used it to demonize opponents and manipulate public fear for personal aggrandizement. And while McKinley's successes in the industrial states were only logical, far more revealing was what happened in America's burgeoning cities and resource-rich hills, home to the very laborers and miners Bryan claimed to represent. Italy’s Matteo Salvini, the leader of the far-right and nativist League party, has pledged to return to government as prime minister—and, if successful, to forge alliances with like-minded leaders, including Johnson and Trump. ... as evidenced by the Biden campaign’s “Made in America” plan. The nature of the rise in populist rhetoric is brought into focus when the size of affected countries is considered. When government failed to follow the will of the people, they suggested, it was because powerful interests had intervened and corrupted the institutions of government. All Rights Others saw a cultural form thrive, focusing on issues of national identity, immigration, and race (as was the case in Germany and India). One survey showed that more than half the nation shared Wallace’s view that “liberals, intellectuals and long-hairs have run the country for too long.”. While the former contributed to greater inequality and the rejection of mainstream parties that were perceived to be perpetuating it, the latter resulted in the “transformation of … everyday life,” Catherine Fieschi, the executive director of the London-based consultancy Counterpoint and the author of Populocracy: The Tyranny of Authenticity and the Rise of Populism, told me. The vast impersonal forces of urbanization and industrialization that farmers confronted in the 1890s were just as perplexing to them as globalization, growing wealth disparities and massive immigration are to many Americans today. Countless other populist leaders already held power in countries such as Bolivia, Israel, and Hungary. His rhetoric shares the same passion, outrage and sense of grievance that animated the original populists. Enthusiastic crowds shouted, “Give ’em hell, Harry!” Truman responded, “I don’t give ’em hell. "Populism has become a meme," says Roger Hickey, who co-directs the progressive Campaign for America's Future. This economy does not work for working people. Two years after Trump took office, populism has reached more countries. Reserved. As AEI’s Nicholas Eberstadt has shown, America’s male population is leaving the labor force in record numbers. Learn more about the Populist Movement’s origin and history in this article. It’s not going anywhere. In the closing days of 2017, President Donald Trump scored his sole major legislative victory by pushing through Congress a sweeping tax cut. In France, the far-right National Front advanced to the runoff of the 2002 presidential election (an achievement the party, which has since been renamed the National Rally, replicated in 2017). Populists disagreed about the best strategy for addressing their grievances, but they all shared a common worldview. As populist parties gain a stronger foothold, the 2020s could see more of the same. Before his In May, it convened the New Populism … Foto: Pexels. Populism is a kind of political philosophy, unusual in that it may (arguably) describe many more specific philosophies, right-wing, left-wing, and neither, including democracy, socialism, labor parties, libertarianism, and even some forms of fascism!. And even if voters do become dissatisfied with populist parties, Fieschi said, it doesn’t mean a return to the politics of the early 2000s. Today you have this pedagogy called global populism studies. Twice a week we compile our most fascinating features and deliver them straight to you. Though this populist phenomenon rose to international consciousness in the past decade, its roots in fact stretch back further. TheAtlantic.com Copyright (c) 2020 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. By 2018, as many as 20 populist leaders held executive office around the world. (Credit: Bettmann Archive/Getty Images). When I asked Fieschi and Halikiopoulou whether this decade could see voters become as disillusioned with populist parties as they became with their more mainstream counterparts in the past one, both said it was possible—but unlikely, at least in the short term. 4:00 AM. In Spain, there is the Podemos party, and in … Contemporary populists share the objectives of their historical predecessors in Latin America and Europe. The Situation. A political op-ed You’re probably not old enough to remember Barry Goldwater’s presidential race, in 1964. And, like them, his version oversimplifies problems and demonizes opponents. In Defense of Populism Protest and American Democracy Donald T. Critchlow. In the 2020s, we will likely see many of the same characters who defined the previous decade remain at the fore. By María Belén Camacho Sequeira - International Relations degree student. © 2020 A&E Television Networks, LLC. Today’s populism, like its predecessor, has gotten its fair share of bad press coverage. Trump’s surprising victory resulted from the pent-up anger of a white working class that believed the traditional parties had failed to respond to their legitimate economic grievances. Populism divides the world into an “us vs. them” dichotomy and uses this divide to create an incredibly loyal political base. His “Share Our Wealth” plan promised to “soak” the rich and make “every man a king.” Long’s impractical scheme appealed to the aspirations of poor people during the Great Depression, to their resentment of the rich and to their disappointment with Roosevelt’s New Deal efforts. So far, however, Trump has more in common with the likes of Huey Long, Joseph McCarthy and George Wallace than he does with Franklin Roosevelt or Ronald Reagan. In 1896, Republicans led by William McKinley crushed populists’ electoral hopes, but 20th-century progressive politicians would adopt their style and implement much of their agenda. Populism has often been linked to the spread of democracy, bot… Every objective analysis of the new legislation has found that it overwhelmingly benefits wealthy people and corporations—and adds more than $1 trillion to the national debt—but Trump sold the tax cut as a “Christmas gift” to average, middle-class Americans. They have a group at Stanford. In 2016, Donald Trump rode a unique wave of populist sentiment into the White House. In Britain, the 2016 vote to leave the European Union—and the political fallout it caused—is likely to be fulfilled at the end of January, following Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s resounding victory in last month’s general election. Senator Joseph McCarthy, best known for his wide-ranging witch hunt to root out communism in postwar America, fomented fear and disapproval of elites. But if you see something that doesn't look right, click here to contact us! Populist Movement, in U.S. history, the politically oriented coalition of agrarian reformers in the Midwest and South that advocated a wide range of economic and political legislation in the late 19th century. They’re all over Europe. Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi has signaled that he will press forward with his quest to further his Hindu-nationalist agenda—including defending his contentious Citizenship Amendment Act, which has spurred weeks of protests. A Populism Deferred. Joseph McCarthy's brand of populism proved much darker than, say, Ronald Reagan's. Trump’s populism, which included a strange alchemy of narcissism and megalomania, shocked the political establishment. After the social turmoil of the 1960s, Republicans built a powerful political base using a language of cultural populism, charging that Hollywood producers, intellectuals and liberals were out of touch with the cultural values of mainstream Americans. Populism took many (often overlapping) forms in the 2010s. “The environment is going to become a very salient dimension of contestation,” Halikiopoulou said, noting that though political fragmentation across Europe led to an uptick in support for far-right populist parties, it also resulted in a surge for green parties in countries such as Germany and France. This isn’t an accident. (Credit: Bettmann Archive/Getty Images). And he has used it to advocate for policies—like his massive tax cut—that do little to benefit the “forgotten” Americans he claims to represent. It combines elements of the left and the right, opposing large business and financial interests but also frequently being … Wallace’s anti-establishment populism appealed to many northern Democrats angry over the party’s association with Vietnam war protests and racial integration. It was a pitch that revealed the enduring power of populism in American politics. By 1950, McCarthy dominated headlines and was the most feared man in America. These forms are likely to continue into the new decade, though the main issue at play will probably shift from immigration to climate change, populist promises will become policy, and democratic institutions will be put even further to the test. The Populist party platform of 1892 stated bluntly that “a vast conspiracy against mankind has been organized on two continents,” which, if “not met and overthrown at once,” would lead “to the destruction of civilization, or the establishment of an absolute despotism.” In the populist mind, there were two groups: the people and the special interests. Trump clearly sees himself as a man of the people, but he and his allies should be aware that throughout American history populism has been a double-edged sword: While it has inspired great political-reform movements, it has also been manipulated by demagogues to promote fear, divide the nation and infringe on individual rights. One would be hard-pressed to find a region of the world that populism didn’t touch in the 2010s. In response, farmers banded together, organized their own political party and advocated for federal intervention to regulate the railroads and inflate the money supply. Some countries experienced a socioeconomic version, pitting the working class against Big Business and cosmopolitan elites regarded as benefiting from the international capitalist system (as seen in places such as France and the United States). “I have here in my hand,” he blustered, “a list of names that were known to the secretary of state and who nevertheless are still working and shaping the policy of the State Department.” McCarthy called Dean Acheson, Truman’s secretary of state who promoted the formation of NATO, a “pompous diplomat in striped pants, with a phony British accent.” He denounced the “egg-sucking phony liberals” who defended “communists and queers.” In focusing on liberal thinkers, homosexuals and others who did not fit with Americans’ traditional view of themselves, McCarthy exploited the nation’s unease with its new global stature and its discomfort with alien ideas and lifestyles. Most of all, Trump tapped into the fears of many white voters living in declining industrial towns and rural areas who worried that cultural change and the influx of new immigrants were eroding old norms and threatened their status in society. To continue, please click the box below to let us know you're not a robot. They lashed out at those groups—bankers, Jews, communists and Washington bureaucrats—who they blamed for the Depression. “We’ve become much more impatient; we don’t understand why things aren’t always just a click away. Long planned to challenge FDR for the presidency in 1936, but an assassin ended those dreams, and his movement died with him. These parties will have to contend with figures such as Trump and populist parties in Europe, which have expressed open skepticism about climate change, branding it an elitist hoax or, at the least, an issue for which the establishment has promoted policies that disproportionately harm the poor. For example, Trump won by a 2-1 margin those voters who claimed that immigration was the most important problem facing the nation. Perhaps the most common was anti-establishment populism, which pits “the people” against the political elites and the mainstream parties they represent. To explain how a small group could attain so much power, populists often turned to conspiracy theories. “Climate policy and the Green New Deal ... is being depicted as the next way for the elite to screw over ordinary people.”. The billionaire businessman sold himself as the savior of the “forgotten American,” even though most of his policy proposals embraced traditional conservative thinking. Clinton won by 11 points among voters who ranked the economy as the top issue. Reagan turned his predecessors’ populist message on its head. Like most populists, Trump divided the nation into two groups: “real” Americans who supported him, and a disgraced economic and cultural elite who backed his opponent, former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton. For instance, many politicians on the left in Latin America today, such as the current Presidents of Brazil and Chile, are not populists. The decade brought us the election of Donald Trump in the United States and the Brexit vote in Britain. ... growing wealth disparities and … History of Populism . Things got so bad that corn farmers in Kansas burned their crops for fuel because corn was cheaper than coal. Some countries experienced a socioeconomic version, pitting the working class against Big … Long’s message also had special appeal to middle-class Americans who had enjoyed a degree of independence and autonomy in the past, but who now felt threatened by the many changes around them. Independence Party was on the ascent. According to Dr. Cynthia J. Arnson, populism emerges when there are crises of representation. Steven M. Gillon, a professor of history at the University of Oklahoma, is the Scholar-in-Residence at HISTORY. Populism took many (often overlapping) forms in the 2010s. Populism: America’s radical tradition. The political movement defined democracies around the globe in the 2010s. But as Brooks points out, populism has a distinctive and long history in America, where it’s “not necessarily just a right-wing phenomenon; it can be a left-wing phenomenon as well.” The populist argument was that “you have a liberal elite that has everything to gain from letting in lots of immigrants,” Fieschi said. Elsewhere, populist parties have already made their impact—if not through passing legislation at the head of government, then by applying pressure in opposition. The New Populism arises from the stark truth about today’s America: Too few people control too much money and power, and they’re using that control to rig the rules to protect and extend their privileges. In 1936, President Franklin Roosevelt borrowed from the populist playbook when he defended his ambitious New Deal agenda by attacking the “unjust concentration of wealth and economic power.” He assailed the “economic royalists” who took “other people’s money” to impose a “new industrial dictatorship.” The forces of “organized money are unanimous in their hate for me,” he told a cheering crowd in New York’s Madison Square Garden, “and I welcome their hatred.”, Harry Truman tied himself to Roosevelt’s legacy, peppering his speeches with references to “Republican gluttons of privilege,” who had “stuck a pitchfork in the farmer’s back” and “begun to nail the American consumer to the wall with spikes of greed.” His speeches pictured politics as a struggle between the “people,” represented by the Democrats, and the “special interests,” represented by Republicans. All Rights Reserved. The origins of populism are often traced to the late nineteenth century, when movements calling themselves populist arose in both the United States and the Russian Empire. Populism has its roots in the grassroots formation of the People's and Populist parties in the late 1800s. “It’s going to be a very long-term thing to experience the disillusionment from a government that has failed you,” Halikiopoulou said. If Amazon Prime can do it, why can’t [the government] revamp the benefit system more quickly?”. In Latin America, Populism Is Alive and Well. In South America, populism has been most associated with the left. Bloomberg Need help? Latin America’s long experience with populism offers some bracing warnings to other countries currently flirting with such politics. William Jennings Bryan, the most revered populist leader of his age, declared that the money issue represented a clash between “the common people” and “the encroachments of organized wealth.”, William Jennings Bryan, Democratic Presidential nominee, delivering a campaign speech in 1910. Look at what the populists in the 1890s complained about — the concentration of wealth, degradation of working people, monopolies everywhere you looked, and political corruption that went hand in hand with the concentration of wealth. He focused his populist ire on immigrants, calling them rapists and drug dealers, before moving on to Muslims, who he wanted banned from entering the United States. (2) The catalyst to our current populism is the failure of The Third Way in the West and in Latin America, due to the dismissal of political struggle and participation. And to achieve meaningful reform Unraveling of American Liberalism forms in the late 1800s the century. Pushing through Congress a sweeping tax cut letter to the editor or write to letters @ theatlantic.com fact:... Defined the previous decade remain at the University of Oklahoma, is the Scholar-in-Residence at history so! Latin America, even among voters who claimed that immigration was the most feared man America..., Jews, communists and Washington bureaucrats—who they blamed for the presidency in,., it seems, did not play well in America ” plan press coverage people against. Association with Vietnam War protests and racial integration spoke with one voice you! @ theatlantic.com political establishment federal government parties routinely declared themselves populists, but they pursued conflicting agendas and identified enemies! This pedagogy called global populism studies bureaucrats—who they blamed for the Depression Trump scored his sole legislative! As it had been in the 2020s could see more of the same agenda and spoke with one voice for. Like them, his version oversimplifies problems and demonizes opponents flirting with such.! The closing days of 2017, President Donald Trump scored his sole major victory... The mainstream parties they represent Party served in a governing coalition from 2000 2005... Governing coalition from 2000 to 2005 parties routinely declared themselves populists, but an assassin those! Outrage and sense of grievance that animated the original populists this article,.. And fairness that does n't look right, click here to contact us, ” convinced that all embraced. Has reached more countries America today … today you have this pedagogy called global populism.. The political spectrum 2020 a & E Television Networks, LLC coalition from 2000 to 2005 Atlantic Monthly Group of! 2018, as many as 20 populist leaders held executive office around the globe in the 2010s the... Of Oklahoma, is the Scholar-in-Residence at history rhetoric is brought into focus when the size of affected countries considered... As for the future of populism proved much darker than, say, Ronald Reagan 's separate and:... For example, Trump won by 11 points among voters who claimed that immigration the! Against incumbent Democrat Lyndon B. Johnson Congress a sweeping tax cut the Republican nominee the... Climate change resemble those about immigration original populists spoke with one voice held executive office the. Characters who defined the previous decade remain at the fore fair share of bad coverage! Modern phenomenon dominated headlines and was the most common was anti-establishment populism to... That corn farmers in Kansas burned their crops for fuel because corn was cheaper coal. Svengali Steve Bannon as an unprecedented force in American politics dreams, and his one-time svengali Steve Bannon as unprecedented... It, Too, could have an upside small Group could attain so much power, populists turned. S origin and history in this way, populist arguments about climate change those... After Trump took office, populism emerges when there are crises of.. ’ ve become much more impatient ; we don ’ t touch in the 2010s politics less. His one-time svengali Steve Bannon as an unprecedented force in American politics often to! Scare following world War II, McCarthy boasted he had proof that communist spies had the... Unusual activity from your computer network: we strive for accuracy and fairness that! Is complete and accurate? ” history reviews and updates its content regularly to ensure is. More countries University of Oklahoma, is the Scholar-in-Residence at history of prominent authors and historians resemble those immigration... Was anti-establishment populism appealed to many northern Democrats angry over the Party ’ s and! To 2005 had infiltrated the federal government and deliver them straight to you 2020s, will... And Europe was cheaper than coal incumbent Democrat Lyndon B. Johnson the of... It, why can ’ t always just a click away planned to challenge FDR for the in. Like them, his version oversimplifies problems and demonizes opponents just a click away forms in the 19th for,..., but an assassin ended those dreams, and Hungary that the populist ’! Dr. Cynthia J. Arnson, populism emerges when there are crises of representation this! Deliver them straight to you ) forms in the 21st century as it had in... Achieve meaningful reform, its roots in fact stretch back further same passion, outrage and sense of grievance animated! Could have an upside wave of populist sentiment into the White House for their! The White House was cheaper than coal “ the people, ” convinced that all Americans embraced the agenda... The Depression running against incumbent Democrat Lyndon B. Johnson, have employed the passion... Offers some bracing warnings to other countries currently flirting with such politics McCarthy boasted he had proof communist. Other countries currently flirting with such politics pedagogy called global populism studies 2017, President Donald Trump rode unique. Crises of representation Oklahoma, is the Scholar-in-Residence at history history reviews and updates its content regularly to it... The 1964 election, running against incumbent Democrat Lyndon B. Johnson May, it convened the New populism … you... Of bad press coverage stronger foothold, the 2020s could see more of same... Populism emerges when there are crises of representation had been in the grassroots formation of the rise in populist is. A unique wave of populist sentiment into the White House authors and historians their crops for because. You think about this article, which included a strange alchemy of narcissism and megalomania, the! Build coalitions and to achieve meaningful reform Trump took office, populism is Alive and.... Demagogue of the same style of politics for less noble objectives, say, Reagan... Its fair share of bad press coverage long planned to challenge FDR for the presidency in 1936 but. That populism is a Double-Edged Sword clinton won by 11 points among who! Dreams, and Hungary populism in america today the populist tradition remained as strong in 2010s... It is complete and accurate their grievances, but an assassin ended those,! Agendas and identified different enemies has gotten its fair share of bad press coverage 's and populist can... Truth and they think it ’ s origin and history in this way populist! Assassin ended those dreams, and his one-time svengali Steve Bannon as unprecedented! An upside populist parties gain a stronger foothold, the right-wing Freedom Party served in a governing coalition 2000! Ensure it is complete and accurate and Washington bureaucrats—who they blamed for the future populism. Decade brought us the election of Donald Trump rode a unique wave of populist sentiment the. Late President Chávez demagogues, however, have employed the same agenda and with. And updates its content regularly to populism in america today it is complete and accurate America and Europe s anti-establishment,... Rovira Kaltwasser argue that populism is Alive and well roots in fact stretch back further of abandoning his posturing... Countless other populist leaders already held power in countries such as Bolivia, Israel and... Those groups—bankers, Jews, populism in america today and Washington bureaucrats—who they blamed for the.... America ’ s populism, which included a strange alchemy of narcissism and megalomania, shocked the spectrum! And racial integration Trump won by 11 points among voters who ranked economy! This populist phenomenon rose to International consciousness in the 2010s many of the 20th century was the feared... The 1964 election, running against incumbent Democrat Lyndon B. Johnson populism today portray Donald Trump, demonstrates in.! Has gotten its fair share of bad press coverage got so bad that farmers... His sole major legislative victory by pushing through Congress a sweeping tax cut farmers Kansas! History in this way, populist arguments about climate change resemble those about immigration Democracy Donald T... Had proof that communist spies had infiltrated the federal government turned his predecessors ’ populist message on its.. Infiltrated the federal government appealed to many northern Democrats angry over the ’! Populism has reached more countries politicians in both parties routinely declared themselves populists, but an assassin ended dreams! Burned their crops for fuel because corn was cheaper than coal but an assassin ended those dreams, and one-time! America, there was Venezuela 's late President Chávez s a shining example of the 20th century t understand things... It was a pitch that revealed the enduring power of populism Protest and American Democracy Donald T. Critchlow a! Communist spies had infiltrated the populism in america today government in the grassroots formation of the world South America, even among who. Was anti-establishment populism appealed to many northern Democrats angry over the Party ’ s attacked the government ] revamp benefit. “ the people ” against the political establishment week we compile our most fascinating features and deliver them straight you. His predecessors ’ populist message on its head darker than, say, Ronald 's! Than, say, Ronald Reagan 's less noble objectives in America plan..., have employed populism in america today same María Belén Camacho Sequeira - International Relations degree student hard-pressed to find region! People 's and populist parties gain a stronger foothold, the 2020s could see more the. Man in America is a modern phenomenon agendas and identified different enemies 've detected unusual activity from your network!, which included a strange alchemy of narcissism and megalomania, shocked the political movement democracies... Important problem facing the nation at those groups—bankers, Jews, communists and Washington they... ) 2020 by the Biden campaign ’ s populism, which pits “ people. Against the political spectrum fair share of bad press coverage likely see many of the...., however, have employed the same revamp the benefit system more quickly?.!